『Abstract
A reliable and economical method for the estimation of nutrient
export (e.g. phosphorus) in stream flow from catchments is necessary
to quantify the impact of land use or land use change upon aquatic
systems. The transport of phosphorus (P) from soil to water is
known to impact negatively on water quality. A key observation
from studies is that most P export occurs during high stream flow.
However, it is not yet clear how flood-antecedent conditions affect
the P export during flood events. In this study, the P loss from
soil to water as represented by soluble reactive phosphorus (SRP)
in stream waters from three different catchments, varying in land
use, scale and location in Ireland was monitored over 1 year.
This study examined the role of antecedent stream flow conditions
on SRP export and identifies a catchment-specific relationship
between SRP flood event load (EL) and a flow ratio (FR). The FR
is defined as the ratio of the flood event volume (EV) to the
pre-event volume (PEV). The latter is the cumulative flow volume
for a number of days preceding the event. This PEV period was
found to be longer (average 81 days) in the grassland catchments
which were known to be saturated with soil P than in the forested
catchments (average 21 days) with minimal soil P. This FR ratio
is a measure of the antecedent hydrological state (wet or dry)
of the catchment. For SRP for each catchment, a specific relationship
between with the concentration/discharge (C/Q) method. The new
flow ratio method was used with data from 12 flood events during
the year to estimate an annual export of SRP. For the two grassland
catchments in the study, using the FR method, we estimated an
SRP export of 1.77 and 0.41 kg ha-1 yr-1.
Using the C/Q method, for the same sites, our estimate of SRP
export was 1.70 and 0.50 kg ha-1 yr-1 respectively.
The C./Q method used SRP concentrations covering 40% of the year
while the FR method used only 12 flood events covering less than
2% of the year. This new method which takes account of the antecedent
flow state of the river is an alternative to and may be more promising
than the traditional C/Q method, particularly when short duration
or flood sampling of water quality is carried out.
Keywords: Water quality; Phosphorus; Runoff; Model; Loads; Ireland』
Introduction
Methods
Study catchments
Dripsey river
Oona river
Douglas forested catchments
Data collection
Stream flow
Water chemistry
Estimation of phosphorus export
C/Q method
Flow ratio method
Event load estimation
Correlation of event load with the flow ratio
Using correlations to estimate annual loads
Dripsey and Oona events
Results
Comparison of water quality results
Comparison of antecedent periods
Comparison of PEVs and ELs
Testing the event selection used in the correlations
Comparison of annual loads from C/Q method and FR method
Discussion
Conclusions
Acknowledgments
References