『Abstract
It is commonly assumed that nitrogen (N) is the primary mineral
resource limiting the productivity of temperate forests. Sustained
inputs of N via atmospheric deposition are altering the N status
of temperate forests raising the possibility that nutrients such
as phosphorus (P) are increasingly limiting productivity. The
objective of this study was to determine whether P availability
limits tree growth alone or in combination with N. This study
was conducted in two forest types common throughout the New England
landscape of the northeastern United States; in sugar maple and
white ash dominated stands growing on base rich parent material
characterized by rapid rates of N cycling and high N availability,
and in red oak-beech-hemlock dominated stands growing on base-poor
parent material characterized by slow rates of N cycling and low
N availability. Starting in 2004, N and P were added to replicate
plots in each forest type in factorial combination at a rate of
150 and 50 kg ha-1 year-1, respectively.
Diameter growth rates of all trees>10 cm DBH were measured in
2005 and 2006 using dendrometer bands and converted into units
of basal area increment (BAI) and wood production. Following 2
years of fertilization, basal area increment in the sugar maple-white
ash forests remained strongly N limited. Fertilization with P
did not significantly increase BAI alone, although both N and
P fertilization tended (P<0.10) to increase diameter growth in
white ash. Wood production in the N-fertilized plots increased
by 100 g C m-2 year-1, roughly doubling
production in the non-fertilized plots. In the red oak-beech-hemlock
stands, there was no overall effect of N or P fertilization on
BAI or wood production because BAI in some species was stimulated
by fertilization with N alone (e.g., black cherry, red oak), while
in other species BAI was unaffected (e.g., red maple, beech) or
negatively affected by fertilization with N or P (e.g., eastern
hemlock). Given that BAI in several tree species responded to
fertilization with N alone and that only one species responded
to P fertilization once N was added, this study suggests that
decades of atmospheric N deposition have not (yet) resulted in
widespread P limitation or saturation of tree demand for N.
Keywords: Nitrogen; Phosphorus; Temperate forest; Nutrient limitation;
Productivity
Introduction
Methods and materials
Study site
Foliage sampling
Soil sampling
N and P fertilization experiment
Data analysis
Results
Foliar and litter N and P
Soil N and P
N and P fertilization experiment
Discussion
Conclusion
Acknowledgments
Appendix
References