wAbstract
@Evidence for abiotic immobilization of nitrogen (N) in soil is
accumulating, but remains controversial. Identifying the fate
of N from atmospheric deposition is important for understanding
the N cycle of forest ecosystems. we studied soils of two Abies
pinsapo fir forests under Mediterranean climate seasonality
in southern Spain - one with low N availability and the other
with symptoms of N saturation. We hypothesized that biotic and
abiotic immobilization of nitrate (NO3-)
would be lower in soils under these forests compared to more mesic
temperate forests, and that the N saturated stand would have the
lowest rates of NO3- immobilization.
Live and autoclaved soils were incubated with added 15NO3- (10Κg N g-1 dry soil;
99 enriched) for 24 h, and the label was recovered as total dissolved-N,
NO3-, ammonium (NH4+),
or dissolved organic-N (DON). To evaluate concerns about possible
iron interference in analysis of NO3-
concentrations, both flow injection analysis (FIA) and ion chromatography
(IC) were applied to water extracts, soluble iron was measured
in both water and salt extracts, and standard additions of NO3- to salt extracts were analyzed.
Good agreement between FIA and IC analysis, low concentrations
of soluble Fe, and 100 (}3) recovery of NO3-
standard additions all pointed to absence of an interference problem
for NO3- quantification. On average,
85 of the added 15NO3-
label was recovered as 15NO3-,
which supports our hypothesis that rates of immobilization were
generally low in these soils. A small amount (mean = 0.06Κg N
g-1 dry soil) was recovered as 15NH4+ in live soils and none in sterilized
soils. Mean recovery as DO15N ranged from 0.6 to 1.5Κg
N g-1 dry soil, with no statistically significant effect
of sterilization or soil type, indicating that this was an abiotic
process that occurred at similar rates in both soils. These results
demonstrate a detectable, but modest rate of abiotic immobilization
of NO3- to DON, supporting our
first hypothesis. These mineral soils may not have adequate carbon
availability to support the regeneration of reducing microsites
needed for high rates of NO3-
reduction. Our second hypothesis regarding lower expected abiotic
immobilization in soils from the N-saturated site was not supported.
The rates of N deposition in this region may not be high enough
to have swamped the capacity for soil NO3-
immobilization, even in the stand showing some symptoms of N saturation.
A growing body of evidence suggests that soil abiotic NO3- immobilization is common, but that
rates are influenced by a combination of factors, including the
presence of plentiful available carbon, reduced minerals in anaerobic
microsites and adequate NO3- supply.
Keywords: Ferrous-wheel hypothesis; Retention; Iron; 15N;
Nitrogen saturation status; Nitrogen cyclex
Introduction
Material and methods
@Site description
@Soil collection, preparation and sterilization
@15NO3- amendment
@15N pool enrichment determination
@Statistical analysis
Results
@Fate of inorganic 15N added to soil
@Nitrate quantification
Discussion
@Methodological concerns
@Fate of 15N-NO3 added to soil
@Factors affecting abiotic retention of NO3-
Acknowledgments
References