『Abstract
In order to determine if the δ15N and δ18O
values of N2O produced during co-oxidation
of NH4+ by methanotrophic (methane
oxidizing) bacteria can be isotopically distinguished from N2O produced either by autotrophic nitrifying or
denitrifying bacteria, we conducted laboratory incubation experiments
with pure cultures of methanotrophic bacteria that were provided
NH4Cl as an oxidation substrate. The N2O produced during NH4+
oxidation by methanotrophic bacteria showed nitrogen isotope fractionation
between NH4+ and N2O
(εN2O-NH4+) of -18 and
-55‰ for Methylomonas methania and Methylosinus trichosporium,
OB3b respectively. These large fractionations are similar to those
previously measured for autotrophic nitrifying bacteria and consist
with N2O formation by multiple rate limiting
steps that include NH4+ oxidation
by the methane monooxygenase enzyme and reduction of NO2-
to N2O. Consequently, N2O
formed by NH4+ oxidation via methanotrophic
or autotrophic nitrifying bacteria might generally be characterized
by lower δ15NN2O values than that formed by denitrification,
although this also depends on the variability of δ15N
of available nitrogen sources (e.g., NH4+,
NO3-, NO2-).
Additional incubations with M. trichosporium OB3b at high
and low CH4 conditions in waters of different
δ18O values revealed that 19-27‰ of the oxygen in N2O was derived from O2 with
the remainder from water. The biochemical mechanisms that could
explain this amount of O2 incorporation are
discussed. The δ18O of N2O formed
under high CH4 conditions was 〜+15‰ more
positive than that formed under lower CH4
conditions. This enrichment resulted in part from the incorporation
of O2 into N2O that
was enriched in 18O due to an isotope fractionation
effect of −16.1±2.0‰ and −17.6±5.4‰ associated with O2
consumption during the high and low methane concentration incubations,
respectively. Therefore, N2O formed by NH4+ oxidation via methanotrophic or
autotrophic nitrifying bacteria can have very positive δ18ON2O
values if the O2 incorporated is previously
enriched in 18O from high rates of respiration. Nitrous
oxide was collected from various depths in soils overlying a coal-bed
methane seep where methanotrophic bacteria are naturally enriched.
In one sampling when soil methane concentrations were very high,
the δ18OVSMOW values of the N2O were highly enriched (+50‰), consistent with
our laboratory experiments. Thus, soils overlying methane seeps
could provide an 18O-enriched source of atmospheric
N2O.
Keywords: Methanotrophy; Nitrification; Atmospheric nitrous oxide;
Oxygen isotopes; Nitrogen isotopes; N2O』
1. Introduction
2. Methods
2.1. Methanotropic bacterial cultures for δ15NN2O
measurements
2.2. Collection of liquid subsamples for cell counts, δ18OH2O
and δ15NNH4+ analyses
2.3. Experiments to determine the contribution of O2
versus H2O oxygen to methanotrophic N2O
2.4. Determination of the isotope fractionation effect for O2 consumption by M. trichosporium
2.5. Stable isotope measurements of H2O
and O2
2.6. Field study of N2O, NH4+
and NO3- from methane-consuming
soils
2.7. Cryogenic purification of headspace N2O
for δ15N and δ18O analysis
2.8. Measurement of δ18ON2O and δ15NN2O
values by isotope ratio mass spectrometry
3. Results
3.1. Methanotrophic cultures
3.2. Methanotrophic cultures, N2O-NH4
3.3. Methanotrophic cultures, N2O-H2O/O2
3.4. Field study of methane-consuming soils
4. Discussion
4.1. Nitrogen isotope fractionation during methanotrophic
oxidation of NH4+ to N2O
4.2. N2O formation - oxidation of hydroxylamine
versus reduction of nitrite
4.3. Comparison of methanotrophic nitrification with previous
proposed mechanisms of N2O formation
4.4. Oxygen isotope fractionation of H2O
and O2 during N2O formation
4.5. δ18ON2O and δ15NN2O values for soils overlying
a thermogenic CH4 seep
5. Conclusions
Acknowledgements
References