Lujala,P.(2009): Deadly combat over natural resources. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 53(1), 50-71.

『天然資源をかけて命がけで戦う』


(Abstract)
 This article empirically examines how natural resources affect the severity of armed civil conflict. It finds that drug cultivation in the conflict area is associated with less severe conflicts but that gemstone mining and oil and gas in the conflict zone production increase the severity of conflicts. Most severe are secessionist conflicts in regions with hydrocarbon production. Interestingly, oil and gas production outside the conflict zones is related to less severe conflicts. Measured at the country level, none of the resource variables has an effect on conflict severity. These results have four implications. First, availability of natural resources affects the severity of armed civil conflict. Second, the location of resources is crucial to their impact on conflict. Third, the type of resource matters. Above all, it seems that natural resources affect conflict severity by altering incentives for both the rebel group and the state.

Keywords: civil war; conflict severity; natural resources; diamonds; oil』

(Introduction)
Natural resources and the severity of conflict
Hypotheses
  Hypothesis 1: Natural resources have an effect on conflict severity when located in the same region as the conflict.
  Hypothesis 2: Gemstone production in the conflict zone is related to less intensive conflicts.
  Hypothesis 3: Drug cultivation in the conflict zone is related to less severe conflicts.
  Hypothesis 4: Oil and gas prouction in the conflict zone is related to more severe conflicts.
  Hypothesis 5: Oil and gas production outside the conflict zone is related to less severe conflicts.
Data
 Resource data
 Dependent variables
 Control variables
  Variables specific to the conflict zone
  Other conflict characteristics
  Variables measured at the country level
  Conflict duration
Analysis
 Natural resources and the total number of combat-related deaths
 Intensity of conflict
 Secessionist aspirations, hydrocarbon production, and conflict severity
 Robustness checks
Discussion of the main results
Notes
References

Table 1. Total combat deaths and conflict duration of armed civil conflict, 1946-2002: Median and mean estimates by type and location of natural resources
 

N

Combat deaths

Duration (Years)

Median

Mean

Median

Mean
All conflicts 258 100 800 20,000 1.9 5.2
Hydrocarbons (Crude oil and natural gas)
 Conflicts in countries with production 159 62 950 21,000 2.0 6.1
 Conflicts in regions with production 75 29 2,100 37,000 1.8 7.8
 Conflicts in countries with production outside conflict zone(s) 129 50 700 9,000 2.0 4.9
Gemstonesa
 Conflicts in countries with production 122 47 1,000 28,000 1.4 6.6
 Conflicts in regions with production 60 23 1,700 49,000 4.0 9.5
Drugs (Coca, opium, cannabis)
 Conflicts in countries with cultivation 78 30 1,000 21,000 4.0 8.7
 Conflicts in regions with cultivation 34 13 1,000 28,000 3.3 9.4
a Includes secondary diamonds and other gemstones such as rubies, sapphires, emeralds, and jade. Primary diamond production excluded.

Table 2. Total combat deaths and average annual death rate of armed civil conflict, 1946-2002: Median and mean estimates by conflict duration

Duration

N

Combat deaths

Intensity

Median

Mean

Median

Mean
<10 days 43 150 400 26,000 74,000
10-30 days 13 200 6,000 3,300 184,000
1-6 months 18 850 2,000 2,000 6,000
6-12 months 33 150 3,000 250 4,000
1-5 years 76 700 24,000 250 7,000
5-10 years 32 7,000 31,000 900 4,000
10-20 years 27 18,000 34,000 1,400 2,000
20-30 years 10 35,000 111,000 1,500 4,000
>30 years 6 17,000 16,000 400 400


ホーム